Thoughts On Spielberg's War Of The Worlds

Right off the bat, I should say that I loved this film. Despite initial resistance to Tom Cruise and feeling burned by both AI (interesting but flawed) and Minority Report (ditto), I was really engrossed and blown away by War Of The Worlds. It is the best sci-fi themed film of the year so far, and one of the better horror films of the last 20 years. That's right, I said horror film!
In spite of being mis-advertised as yet another slam-bang summer sci-fi action movie, Spielberg's War Of The Worlds is truly a horror film, or even more accurately, a disaster horror film. And, I believe much of the criticism leveled at it centers on this misconception. Many people, including myself, found War Of The Worlds very disturbing and not terribly pleasurable to experience. Independence Day, this is not! But, I contend that that was the very point of the movie. The fact that you leave the film feeling psychologically assaulted and shaken is testament to Spielberg's power as a storyteller. Not all art is pleasurable, nor should it all be. Many horror films are fun, but the ones I love the best are the ones that make me want to take a hot shower afterward, and it's great that there are some filmmakers left in the world who have the guts to provoke an audience in this way.
There has also been a lot of criticism of Spielberg's use of 9/11 imagery in the film. Many reviews have contended that this was done purposely by the director in order to manipulate the audience into reliving a traumatic experience and therefore heightening the drama. I couldn't disagree more. We (Spielberg included) are now more knowledgable of how people in the real world react to a major disaster, and to not portray this would have made it less realistic and done a disservice to the film. Spielberg may be accused of blatantly tugging the audience's heartstrings in the past, but here he is at his most raw and powerful as a filmmaker.



